HITTING THE NAIL
Responses to "Natural Born Thriller," by Robert Hilburn (Oct. 2)
Hilburn's interview with Trent Reznor bothered me enough to prevent a return
to sleep at 3:30 in the morning. Both Reznor's attitudes and Hilburn's
indulgence of them were troubling.
I found the image of a young boy singing, "I want to (expletive) you like an
animal" particularly disturbing. (Before the publication of the article, a
19-year-old female acquaintance, a huge Nine Inch Nails fan, mentioned that
a 14-year-old had sung those same words to her. Her attitude seemed to be
"Those kr-aazy kids. . . ."). Hilburn lets that image pass without comment. I
believe it begs a question: Where are we when a kid of that age identifies with
I believe that achievement is driven by expectation and vision. Tom Lehrer
once said, "Life is like a sewer. What you get out depends on what you put
in." Lehrer was blessed with both a sense of humor and irony. Both appear to
be woefully lacking in Reznor's case.
If the purpose of art is to have people view things differently, to what end
does that work? The result does not appear in a vacuum. What new and
hopeful perspective can the average adolescent gain when viewing through a
lens of violence, perversion and death?
Should an emotionally mature person have the option to listen to music or
read material that plumbs the depths of existence? I think absolutely yes. I
think it could be beneficial.
Should an adolescent who has only recently gained secondary sex
characteristics and whose psyche is often confused at best be wading in that?
I think not. Parents must instill a positive vision in their children.
Unfortunately, they also must actively guide, or even dictate at times, what is
appropriate for their consumption.
I fear that we have already created a moral, cultural Blob. If you step in it,
you not only can't scrape it off your shoe, it eats you and goes looking for
In recent stories, Robert Hilburn has blurred some facts concerning the
relationship between Trent Reznor and the soundtrack to the movie "Natural
The truth is that Reznor did not oversee the selection of the individual songs
and music for the film itself. The creative decisions were made by the
producers, film editors and music editors under the supervision of director
Oliver Stone, with Stone having final approval.
From this collection of songs, Reznor made his selections to be included in his
self-produced soundtrack CD, which turned out to be a fine production,
It seems that this distinction was lost amid Hilburn's sweeping adulation of
I enjoyed most of Robert Hilburn's cover story on Trent Reznor. Nine Inch
Nails is a unique force in music, deserving all of its recent success.
However, Hilburn was way off the mark in attributing Reznor's female fanship
to his sex appeal. Men and women are equally capable of feeling rage, lust
and alienation. I listen to Trent Reznor for his brutally honest exploration of
the depths of the human soul.
Thank you, Robert Hilburn, for showing everyone that Trent Reznor smiles
and breathes like everyone else. He is human like you and me. His songs are
from the hurt that lies within him, and if you think about it, the love that is
within him also. For that, he is a beautiful person.
In the past, I have hurt just as badly as he has and have loved someone that I
could never have. Trent is human just as I am. There is nothing wrong with his
songs. They are based on his beliefs, his world. I can relate to his feelings, his
hurt and his loneliness.
I would like to thank Robert Hilburn for introducing us to yet another new
"genius," Trent Reznor. If he can produce the line "I want to (expletive) you
like an animal" while still in his 20s, we can only imagine what his "artistry"
and "vision" can produce in the years to come.
<< Previous Page
is provided courtesy Keith Duemling and Tracy Thompson from the collection previously
located at SUS.